Order Online - For local Manhattan delivery
Additional items are available via phone order. Please see our Bakery options in the menu above.
For any orders requiring shipping via Federal Express, outer boroughs, or Manhattan Hotel delivery
please call 212-580-5130 or 718-806-1854
(P)-Pareve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut (V)-Vegan
Shabbat Gift Bags (P)
Granola (P)-Pareve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut (V)-Vegan
Cookies (P)-Parve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut
Cupcakes & Cake Pops (P)-Parve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut
-
Dinosaur Cupcakes – Pack of 4 (mix/match) (P)
$25.00 Select options -
Dinosaur cupcake (P) – Individual
$6.25 -
Character Cupcakes – Pack of 4 (mix/match) (P)
$25.00 Select options -
Elmo Cupcake (P)
$6.25 -
Cookie Monster Cupcake (P)
$6.25 -
Ernie Cupcake (P)
$6.25 -
Bert Cupcake (P)
$6.25 -
Oscar Cupcake (P)
$6.25 -
Big Bird Cupcake (P)
$6.25 -
Dog Design Cupcake (P)
$6.25 -
Seasonal Cupcakes – Pack of 4 (mix/match) (P)
$25.00 Select options -
Miniature Cupcakes – Pack of 12 (mix/match) (P)
$33.00 Select options -
Cupcakes – Pack of 4 (mix/match) (P)
$15.00 Select options -
Assorted Cake Pops (P) Dozen
$27.00 Add to cart
Cakes (P)-Parve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut
-
Grandmas Patriotic Apple Cake (P) (S)
$42.00 – $58.00 -
Strawberry Shortcake (Dairy) (Curbside Pickup Only – LIC Queens)
$55.00 – $80.00 -
Flourless Chocolate Cake (P GF)
$50.00 – $78.00 -
Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Mousse (P) – 8″ Serves 8-12
$45.00 Add to cart -
Marjolaine Cake (P GF NT S) – Serves 8-12
$58.00 Add to cart -
Grandma’s Apple Cake – (TIN) (P) (S) Serves 6-8
$32.00 Add to cart -
Whiteout Cake (P) – 6” Serves 6-8
$38.00 Add to cart -
Mocha Cake – (P) 6” Serves 6-8
$38.00 Add to cart -
Old Fashion Coconut (P) – 6” Serves 6-8
$38.00 Add to cart -
Campfire Cake – (P) Serves 8-10
$50.00 Add to cart -
Scott’s Birthday Cake (P)(NT) – 8”
$48.00 Add to cart -
Blackout Birthday Design Cake -6″serves 4-6 Includes Inscription (P)
$40.00 -
Ribbon Cake (P) – 8″ Serves 8-12
$45.00 Add to cart -
Blackout Cake (P) (S) – 8″ Serves 8-12
$45.00 Add to cart -
Shadow Cake (P) – 8″ Serves 8-12
$45.00 Add to cart -
Peanut Butter Mousse Cake (Dairy)(NT) – 8″ Serves 8-12
$55.00 Add to cart -
Carrot Cake w/ Cream Cheese Frosting (Dairy)(NT) – 8″ Serves 8-12
$55.00 Add to cart -
Chocolate Truffle Cake (Dairy)
$50.00 – $75.00 -
White Chocolate Mousse Cake (Dairy)
$55.00 – $80.00 -
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake (Dairy)
$55.00 – $78.00 -
Marble Cheesecake (Dairy)
$55.00 – $78.00 -
Plain Cheesecake (Dairy)
$55.00 – $78.00 -
Deep Dish Apple Crumb Cake – (P) 8″ Serves 8-12
$45.00 Add to cart
Loaf Cakes (P)-Parve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut
Pies & Tarts (P)-Parve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut
-
S’mores Pie (P) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Pumpkin Pie (P) (S) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pecan Tart (P)(NT) (S) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$32.00 Add to cart -
Lemon Meringue Tart (P) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$32.00 Add to cart -
Raspberry Linzer Tart (P)(NT) (V) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Plum Tart (P) (S) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb Tart – (P) 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Pecan Pie (P)(NT) (S) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$32.00 Add to cart -
Apple Pie (P) (S) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (P) (S) – 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Lemon Tart – (P) 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart -
Apple Tart – (P) 8″ Serves 6-8
$30.00 Add to cart
Challah, Breads, Buns (P)-Parve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut
-
Heart Challah (P)
$12.00 Add to cart -
Key Challah (P)
$10.00 Add to cart -
Whole Wheat Challah-(P)
$7.50 Add to cart -
Homemade Breadsticks – Dozen (P)(V)
$8.00 Add to cart -
Chocolate Chip Pull Challah (P)
$8.50 Add to cart -
Raisin Challah (P)
$8.00 Add to cart -
Burger Buns (P)(bag of 6)
$7.50 -
Marzipan Challah-(P) (NT)
$12.00 Add to cart -
Challah Rolls- Bag of 6-(P)
$7.50 Add to cart -
Brioche Challah-(P)
$9.00 Add to cart -
Plain Challah-(P)
$7.50 Add to cart -
Chocolate Challah Twists – (P) $2.50/each
$2.50 Add to cart -
Circle Of Life Challah-(P)
$15.00 Add to cart
Cookie & Fruit Platters
Homemade Soup (P)-Pareve (V)-Vegan
Quiche (Please call for availability)
![]() | Plain Quiche (Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $48.00 | | $48.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Mushroom Quiche-(Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $48.00 | | $48.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Spinach Quiche-(Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $48.00 | | $48.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Broccoli Quiche-(Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $48.00 | | $48.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Cheese Lasagna (Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 6
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $48.00 | | $48.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Roasted Vegetable Lasagna (D) Contains Dairy
Serves 6
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $50.00 | | $50.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Macaroni & Cheese (Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 6
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $48.00 | | $48.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Wild Poached Salmon-Pareve Per Portion | $23.95 | | $23.95 | Add to cart |
![]() | Dill Sauce (Dairy) Contains Dairy
8 Ounces Complements our Fresh Poached Salmon | $12.00 | | $12.00 | Add to cart |
![]() | Caesar Salad Kit (Dairy) Allergens: Dairy, Gluten
Serves 6 -
Homemade Croutons
Homemade Parmesan Toasts
Homemade Creamy Caesar Dressing
Grated Parmesan Cheese
All you need to complete this delicious Caesar Salad is Fresh Crisp Hearts of Romaine Lettuce | $48.00 | | $48.00 | Add to cart |
To place a bakery order for pickup please call or order online before 2:00 pm – 212.580.5130
For specialty cake, specialty dessert and custom cake orders, we need a minimum 72-hour advance notice
There are no refunds or exchanges on bakery products, specialty cake, and dessert orders Cancellation policy: Custom Cakes: Two days notice for a full refund, Wedding Cakes: Five days notice for a full refund
My Most Favorite Food is not responsible for custom cake orders once they leave our premises
My Most Favorite Food is not a nut free environment. Please contact us with any allergy concerns.
My Most Favorite Food
Tuesday - Wednesday 10:00 am - 4:00 pm
Thursday - 9:30 am - 4:00 pm
Friday - 9:30 am - 2:00 pm.
Please place orders by 2pm for next day local delivery.
Please call for shipping options.