High Holiday Menu
Rosh Hashanah: Last day to advance order is Monday, September 15 2025
(Rosh Hashanah Federal Express orders shipping overnight Thursday to arrive Friday)
Yom Kippur: Last day to advance order is Thursday, September 25 2025
(P)-Pareve (D)-Dairy (GF)-Gluten Free (NT)-Nut (V)-Vegan (S)-Shipping
Cookies (Dozen, Pareve)
Brownies (Pareve)
Cakes (Pareve)
Inscribed Chocolate Disc available at checkout
-
Deep Dish Apple Crumb Cake (P) 8″
$50.00 Add to cart -
Blackout Cake (P)(S) 8″
$55.00 Add to cart -
Whiteout Cake (P) – 6” Serves 6-8
$40.00 Add to cart -
Grandma’s Apple Cake – (TIN)(P)(S)
Price range: $34.00 through $50.00 -
Marjolaine Cake (P)(GF)(NT)(S)
$65.00 Add to cart -
Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Mousse (P) 8″
$55.00 Add to cart -
Shadow Cake (P) 8″
$55.00 Add to cart -
Ribbon Cake (P) 8″
$55.00 Add to cart -
Anniversary Disc (P) (GF)
$15.00 Add to cart -
Happy Birthday Chocolate Disc (P) (GF)
$15.00 Add to cart
Cakes (Dairy, Pickup Only)
-
Carrot Cake w/ Cream Cheese Frosting (Dairy)(NT) 8″
$60.00 Add to cart -
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake (Dairy) 8″
$60.00 Add to cart -
Marble Cheesecake (Dairy) 8″
$60.00 Add to cart -
Plain Cheesecake (Dairy) 8″
$60.00 Add to cart -
White Chocolate Mousse Cake (Dairy) 8″
$70.00 Add to cart -
Chocolate Truffle Cake (Dairy) 8″
$65.00 Add to cart -
Peanut Butter Mousse Cake (Dairy)(NT) 8″
$65.00 Add to cart
Loaf Cakes (Pareve)
Pies & Tarts (Pareve)
-
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pecan Tart (P)(NT)(S)
Price range: $34.00 through $48.00 -
Plum Tart (P)(S)
Price range: $32.00 through $46.00 -
Apple Pie (P)(S)
Price range: $32.00 through $46.00 -
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (P)(S)
Price range: $32.00 through $46.00 -
Lemon Tart (P)
Price range: $32.00 through $46.00 -
Apple Tart (P)
Price range: $32.00 through $46.00
Round Challah (Pareve)
Homemade Soup
Savory (Please call for availability)
![]() | Broccoli Quiche-(Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $49.00 | | Add to cart |
![]() | Cheese Lasagna (Dairy) Serves 6 Contains Dairy
Serves 6
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $50.00 | | Add to cart |
![]() | Eggplant Rollatini (portion – 2 pieces) Dairy-Gluten-Oven Fried Eggplant filled with Ricotta Cheese, Wilted Spinach, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese baked in our Homemade San Marzano Tomato Sauce
Reheating Instructions: Cover with aluminum foil, reheat in 350-degree oven for 15 minutes | $15.95 | | Add to cart |
![]() | Macaroni & Cheese (Dairy) Serves 6 Contains Dairy
Serves 6
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $48.00 | | Add to cart |
![]() | Mushroom Quiche-(Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $49.00 | | Add to cart |
![]() | Plain Quiche (Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $49.00 | | Add to cart |
![]() | Roasted Vegetable Lasagna (D) Serves 6 Contains Dairy
Serves 6
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $52.00 | | Add to cart |
![]() | Spinach Quiche-(Dairy) Contains Dairy
Serves 8 - 10
Reheating Instructions:
Cover with aluminum foil
Reheat 25-30 minutes or until desired temperature in preheated 350-degree oven | $49.00 | | Add to cart |
My Most Favorite Food, an exclusive kosher bakery, offers mouthwatering desserts featuring parve, dairy, gluten-free, and lactose-intolerant options. In addition to our extensive selection of desserts, we offer pareve and dairy catering to meet your individual needs.
Cancellation Policy:
There are no refunds or exchanges on bakery products, specialty cakes, desserts, and food orders.
Standard Orders: 48-hour notice is required in writing.
Holiday Orders: 14-day notice is required in writing.
Custom Cake, Wedding Cake Orders: require a ten-day notice in writing.
My Most Favorite Food is not responsible for custom cake orders once they leave our premises.
My Most Favorite Food is not a nut-free or gluten free environment. Please contact us with any allergy concerns
Manhattan Delivery Information*
Orders placed 24 hours in advance-$8.00 Fee for
Residential Deliveries between 61st St. & 96th St.
Please Note: Holiday Delivery Fees May Vary
*Same-day orders, corporate/office buildings, 97th St. - 114th St. and
Sunday Deliveries-61st St. - 114th St.-$15.00 Fee
Deliveries below 61st Street - Lower Manhattan
115th Street-125th Street
Hospitals & Hotels-$20.00 Fee
Specialty Dessert Orders, Custom Cakes, Wedding Cakes, Catering Orders - Delivery Fee priced accordingly.
Please call 212.580.5130 for Delivery Fee to
Above 125th Street in Manhattan, Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, Westchester, Long Island, and New Jersey
Outer Borough Delivery Information
Orders placed 24 hours in advance-$40.00 fee for residential deliveries to Riverdale, Brooklyn, Queens, Lower Westchester, Great Neck, Five Towns, Teaneck and Englewood NJ (Atlantic Beach fee may vary slightly)
Please Note: Holiday and same-day order delivery fee may vary.
Nationwide shipping is available. Call for details.
Place your orders by Noon for next day Manhattan delivery
My Most Favorite Food
Monday - Thursday - 9:30 am - 4:00 pm
Friday - 9:30 am - 2:00 pm.
Please place orders by Noon for next day local delivery.
Please call for shipping options.
t 212-580-5130 or 718-806-1854 | f 718-361-0288 | Contact Us
37-22 13th Street, Long Island City, NY 11101
My Most Favorite Food does NOT claim to be a nut-free, soy-free, wheat-free, or gluten-free facility. For your own safety we recommend anyone with highly allergic reactions or Celiac Disease to take caution when consuming our products and at their own risk.