Bakery - Pies & Tarts

(P)-Parve (D)-Dairy (NT)-Nut

  Prices$15 - 20$28 - 32$42 - 47
  Prices$18 - 24$30 - 35$42 - 47


All cakes available by the slice - $9.50

Inscriptions, personalization and delivery are available at an additional cost.

Other specialty desserts available upon request.

For specialty cake or specialty dessert orders we need a minimum of 48-hour advance notice

To place a bakery order for next day delivery please call before 3:00 pm - 212.580.5130

Apple Pie (P)

*Blueberry Pie (P)

*Peach Pie (P) (NT)

Pecan Pie (P)
(6"-$19, 8"-$32, 10"-$44)

*Pumpkin Pie (P)

Smores Pie (P)
(6"-$18, 8"-$30, 10"-$44)

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (P)

*Key Lime Pie
(6"-$20, 8"-$32, 10"-$44)

Apple Tart (P)

Plum Tart (P)

*Blueberry Tart (P)

Peach Tart

Coconut Custard Tart
(6"-$20, 8"-$32, 10"-$44)

Chocolate Pudding Tart

Chocolate Hazelnut Tart (NT)
(6"-$19, 8"-$32, 10"-$44)

Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb Tart

Pear Tart (NT)

Raspberry Linzer Tart (NT)

Lemon Tart (P)

Chocolate Truffle Tart (P)

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pecan Tart (P) (NT)
(6"-$19, 8"-$32, 10"-$44)

Lemon Meringue Tart (P)
(6"-$20, 8"-$32, 10"-$44)

Fresh Fruit Tart (D)
with strawberries, blueberries, kiwi and french pastry cream

To place a bakery order for pickup please call or order online before 2:00 pm – 212.580.5130

For specialty cake, specialty dessert and custom cake orders, we need a minimum 72-hour advance notice

There are no refunds or exchanges on bakery products, specialty cake, and dessert orders Cancellation policy: Custom Cakes: Two days notice for a full refund, Wedding Cakes: Five days notice for a full refund

My Most Favorite Food is not responsible for custom cake orders once they leave our premises

My Most Favorite Food is not a nut free environment. Please contact us with any allergy concerns.

My Most Favorite Food
247 West 72nd Street, New York, NY 10023

We are here for you and open for business with limited hours
Closed Monday - Open Tuesday - Thursday 11:00 am - 8:00 pm
Friday 9:30 am - 2:00 pm, Sunday 11:00am - 6:00pm
We are now open for OUTDOOR DINING and continuing to deliver to your home

t 212 580 5130   |   f 212 580 5135   |   Contact Us